Since the installment of Barrack Obama as our Commander in Chief, I know many, myself included, who are frustrated with his constant utterance of the word “democracy” to refer to the United States. Yes, it’s true – America is a democracy. But first and foremost, America is a REPUBLIC with a CONSTITUTION in place to safeguard certain inalienable rights, which cannot be overturned no matter how large the majority against them is. For instance, in America, even if 99.99% of the population is against private gun ownership, the right to bear arms cannot be overturned. It’s one of our inalienable rights established by the Bill of Rights (the first 10 amendments), and thus permanently out of the reach of any collection of citizens against it.
The essential difference between a Republic and a Democracy is the driving force that separates the American identity and value system from the rest of the world. The essential aspect of a Democracy is the belief that ALL of our rights come from government, i.e. other elected human beings. The essential aspect of a Republic is the belief that ALL of our rights come from God, or, for atheists, are possessed innately. The humans we elect to government are simply meant to protect those rights from infringement by other humans. Bearing this info in mind, I can only shake my head over the many who align themselves as strict Constitutionalists and/or “Republicans” (whatever that means) who are also rejoicing over the Swiss referendum to ban the construction of minarets.
REFRESHER ALERT: According to Wikipedia, “Minarets are distinctive architectural features of Islamic mosques. Minarets are generally tall spires with onion-shaped or conical crowns, usually either free standing or taller than any associated support structure.” Essentially, the Muslim version of a Church steeple. See the picture below? They’re the tall, pointy things. And on Monday, 57.5% of Switzerland’s voting population voted to ban them. Well, future construction of them.
Unfortunately for real Constitutionalists, the right to private property and freedom of religion are two of those inalienable, God-given rights, and we don’t have the authority to inhibit the rights of anyone who isn’t interfering in anyone else’s life just because we happen to disagree with them. Sucks, I know.
The flaw in a Democracy is that it leads to a problem referred to as the tyranny of the majority, whereby the God-given rights of 49.9% of people can be overturned by 50.1% The beauty in a Republic is that our God-given rights are protected at all times from all levels of resistance. As long as you’re not interfering in others’ lives, you’re right to own property and do with it as you please cannot be inhibited. As long as you’re not harming anyone else, you’re right to practice your religion cannot be infringed upon.
This little aspect of Republicanism comes especially in handy during periods of heated emotionalism when we tend to make irrational decisions that we would not normally make. We are in one of those periods. Currently, Americans harbor great animosity toward the Muslim community, and although many don’t understand why (see my article “Endless Wars, Policy Breakdowns and Getting Screwed”), the Muslim community harbors great animosity toward Americans. But we cannot let anger and fear guide us into shortsighted decisions. How quickly we forget the lessons of Nazi Germany. And let’s not lose grasp of the percentage of Muslims who can actually be classified as radical.
Furthermore, the Ghost is indignant over the level of inconsistency of some people. The same people who champion this illicit oppression of peaceful Muslims are terrified of government health care (and rightfully so) because it will open the door for government to usurp all sorts of rights. While the Ghost agrees with this assessment, he must point out that the same pitfall is inherent in the consequences of the Swiss referendum. Once the government can ban the construction of minarets, where does this power end? I’m certain that the self-important new bureaucrats created to oversee this sort of referendum will be eager to expand their own liberties while sacking ours.
In Switzerland, their decision to ban minaret construction, while not justifiable, is understandable. Considering their form of government, Europeans have much to be fearful about. A large influx of Muslims combined with white liberalism could cause many of their God-given rights to be overturned, and especially fearful should be women. Such is the downfall of Democracy.
In America, however, we must allow strength to guide our decision-making. FEAR is the mark of Democracy, but STRENGTH is the character of Republicanism. As long as the acid of Democracy is not allowed to dissolve the idea of the Republic, God will provide the strength needed to overcome our challenges.